A post going viral on social media claims that police officers in Austin, Texas, can now fail their written promotion exam and still be promoted to sergeant or lieutenant, and that the city made the change in the name of diversity. The claim is partly true but leaves out important details.
Flashinfong checked the agreement between the City of Austin and the Austin Police Association, the officers’ union. It does remove the minimum pass mark for the written exam on its own. But candidates still have to reach a combined score of 70% across the written exam and a separate practical assessment before they can move forward.
What the contract actually says
For the ranks of sergeant and lieutenant, the agreement states that there is no minimum passing score for the written examination. In the same section, it sets a minimum passing score of 70% for the written exam and the assessment centre combined. A candidate who misses that combined mark does not move forward in the process.
The two parts are weighted equally, with each score multiplied by 0.5. Points for time in rank and education are then added to produce the final promotion list. Under the previous system, officers needed at least 70 out of 100 on the written test just to go through to the next stage, according to the police trade publication Law Officer.
In practice, this means a weak written score can be balanced by a strong assessment-centre performance. Law Officer gave the example of a candidate who scores 40 on the written test but does well enough in the assessment centre to bring the average to 70.
The assessment centre is a practical evaluation in which a panel scores candidates on role-play exercises and real-life supervisory scenarios.
Not a new change
Although the posts present it as fresh news, the rule is not new. It is part of the Meet and Confer Agreement approved in 2024, which runs until September 2029. A May 2025 city notice for the police lieutenant assessment centre already stated that there was no minimum written score to take part, Law Officer reported.
The topic went viral again this month after a Law Officer article published on 15 November and a series of posts on X.
Why the city made the change
City presentation materials on the 2024 agreement list “increased diversity opportunities for promotions” as one of the improvements to the promotion process, according to Law Officer.
The change follows a 2022 report by the consultancy Kroll, commissioned by the city’s Office of Police Oversight, which found that the written promotion test may have an adverse impact on candidates of colour and recommended reviewing how the tests were weighted. Studies of police and fire services have generally found that assessment centres produce smaller differences between racial groups than written tests.
The arguments on both sides
Critics, including many conservative commentators and some police voices online, say removing the written pass mark lowers standards for leadership roles that require detailed knowledge of law, policy and procedure. They argue that a sergeant or lieutenant should be able to pass a written test on the rules they will enforce and supervise.
Supporters say the written test was a barrier that did not reliably predict who would make a good supervisor. They argue the assessment centre is a better measure of leadership, judgement and communication, and that the 70% combined requirement still keeps a clear minimum standard.
Flashinfong did not find a public statement from the Austin Police Association or the Austin Police Department responding to the latest wave of criticism.
What happens next
The rules will stay in place for promotion lists under the current agreement unless the city and the union renegotiate them. The debate is likely to continue, as police promotion tests in several US cities face similar arguments over fairness, standards and diversity.
Sources: City of Austin–Austin Police Association Meet and Confer Agreement (2024), Law Officer.






