A Federal High Court sitting in Abuja on Wednesday declared former Benue State governor Gabriel Suswam the valid candidate of the All Progressives Congress (APC) for the Benue North-East senatorial district in the 2027 elections, overturning the party’s decision to field the incumbent senator, Emmanuel Udende. According to The Sun, Justice Ekwo ordered the APC to forward Suswam’s name to the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) as its rightful candidate for the seat.
The judgment reverses the fortunes of two men who have fought over the same district for years, and adds to a growing list of pre-election disputes that courts are being asked to settle before the 2027 general elections.
What the court decided
Suswam went to court in a suit marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1470/2026, naming the APC, Senator Udende and INEC as defendants. He asked the court to recognise him as the duly nominated candidate of the party, arguing that he won the APC primary but was later substituted without legal basis.
According to The Sun and TheGuild, Suswam told the court he polled 131,083 votes at the primary held on 18 May 2026, while Udende scored 1,364 votes, figures attributed to the APC’s National Assembly Primary Election Committee. Despite that declaration, the party later submitted Udende’s name to INEC as its candidate.
The central question before the court was whether a political party can lawfully replace the winner of its own primary without meeting the conditions set out in the Electoral Act and the party’s guidelines. Justice Ekwo ruled in Suswam’s favour, affirming him as the winner of the primary.
INEC’s position in court
A notable moment in the case came from the electoral commission itself. Vanguard, citing the News Agency of Nigeria, reported that INEC’s counsel, Anthony Malik (SAN), told the court at an earlier hearing that the commission’s documents on the conduct of the primary showed Suswam won. He urged the court to decide the dispute in line with the result of that primary.
Suswam was represented by Jibrin Okutepa (SAN), who asked the court to grant all the reliefs sought and to throw out preliminary objections filed by the APC and Udende. The party and the senator had asked the court to dismiss the suit. As of Wednesday, there was no public statement from either the APC or Udende on whether they would challenge the judgment at the Court of Appeal.
A long rivalry in Zone A
The ruling is the latest twist in a contest that dates back to the 2023 elections. At the time, Suswam was the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) senator for Benue North-East, while Udende ran on the APC platform. INEC declared Udende the winner of the February 2023 poll.
As TheCable reported at the time, the election petition tribunal later cancelled thousands of votes and declared Suswam the winner in September 2023, but the Court of Appeal reversed that decision and restored Udende as senator. Udende has represented the district, also known as Zone A, in the 10th Senate since then.
Suswam, who governed Benue from 2007 to 2015, later moved to the APC, setting up a direct contest with Udende for the party’s ticket ahead of 2027.
Wider shake-up in Benue politics
The judgment comes on the same day that the opposition in Benue claimed a notable political gain. BusinessDay, Vanguard and Leadership reported that seven former commissioners who served in Governor Hyacinth Alia’s APC administration have declared support for the PDP governorship candidate, Michael Aondoakaa (SAN).
The group includes former commissioners for agriculture, humanitarian affairs, lands, women affairs, cooperatives, power and information. The PDP described the move as a vote of confidence in Aondoakaa, while Aondoakaa promised to focus on unity, security and inclusive development if elected. Governor Alia’s camp had not publicly responded to the defections at the time of writing.
What happens next
If the judgment stands, INEC is expected to recognise Suswam as the APC candidate for Benue North-East once the party complies with the court’s order. The APC and Udende have the option of appealing, and pre-election appeals in Nigeria are subject to strict timelines under the Constitution and the Electoral Act.
The case also adds to pressure on parties over how they manage primaries. Several candidate disputes have reached the courts in recent weeks, and rulings such as this one reinforce the principle that the person who wins a valid primary is the person a party must present to INEC.
Sources: The Sun, Vanguard (NAN), TheGuild, TheCable, BusinessDay, Leadership.








